Monday, June 12, 2017

Who Review: "Empress of Mars" (Series 10, Episode 9)

WARNING: SPOILERS, sweetie.


It figures that in an episode featuring Game of Thrones’ Meryn Traunt, everything winds up being his fault in some way.

In “Empress of Mars”, NASA has discovered a strange message on the red planet: “God Save the Queen.” The Doctor takes the TARDIS to the planet in the year 1881 – when the message apparently originated – to discover an army of Victorian soldiers, who are mining the planet after apparently striking up a deal with an Ice Warrior. But the selfishness of humanity leads to the awakening of the titular Empress of Mars and her army of dormant Ice Warriors, and war is on the horizon. Separated from Nardole and the TARDIS, the Doctor and Bill must play peacekeeper.

This season has been filled with really intriguing concepts for episodes, and this one continues that trend. It’s not often than humans are the alien invaders of an episode, and it was a nice touch having this episode after an entire trilogy based around a more traditional (but really not all that traditional) alien invasion.

I also like the morally conflicting situation this puts the Doctor in. The Ice Warriors have had their home planet invaded and exploited for mining opportunities, with one of their soldiers essentially forced into servitude. They’re definitely in the wrong here, but the Doctor can’t completely advocate for their side, as the Ice Warriors have much more advanced artillery than the humans’ Victorian-era firearms and would completely annihilate their invaders. Both sides can be seen in a sympathetic or antagonistic light, with neither side being fully in the right or wrong.

It’s nice to see the return of the Ice Warriors, a seldom-seen species in Doctor Who that I find oddly fascinating. In the classic series, they were much more plentiful, and have only made a few scant appearances in the revival. They’ve always been frightening simply by how much power and ferocity they possess. Those suits aren’t just big turtle shells; they’re high-tech armor casings that basically make the Ice Warriors big, lumbering, indestructible tanks. And those weapons they have that can somehow contort humans into fatal cubes…lordy.

"Make my monsters grow!!"


Iraxxa – the Empress of Mars – is a fresh sight, as giving the Ice Warriors a singular monarch was never a concept before. And I dig her design, with her Predator-like dreadlocks giving her a more distinct appearance than her underlings. Although, I wish there were more aspects like this that set her apart from the other Ice Warriors. I was kind of hoping that for a warrior race like this, their queen would show off far more tactical prowess than her soldiers. For example, maybe she could be a more agile combatant in her suit than other Ice Warriors, showing that in this society, might is what makes a monarch. Or maybe I just got caught up too much in her Predator-esque appearance and expected too much.

Regardless, on the Moffat Monster Scare-o-meter™, Iraxxa and the Ice Warriors score 3 Moffs out of 5.

The episode also has a decently satisfying character arc involving the commanding officer of the Victorian soldiers, who survived being hanged for desertion and redeems himself at the end by killing his traitorous and bloodthirsty second-in-command and making peace with the Ice Warriors. Though, I’m not quite sure how I feel about him swearing complete allegiance to Iraxxa to make peace. Wouldn’t that mean that his surviving soldiers would be pledging their allegiance to Mars instead of England (assuming that the rest of them stayed on the planet with him)? I don’t really think this is something a dedicated soldier would do – with my conception being that they would rather die for their country than surrender to a new master – but maybe the colonel’s cowardice has something to do with this decision.

So after the mystery of the Vault has been solved, a new enigma has popped up: The TARDIS apparently transports itself off of Mars and back into the Doctor’s office on Earth. Nardole is apparently unable to pilot it – despite previously being shown able to – and requires Missy’s help to get it back to 1881 Mars. Could this be the TARDIS itself trying to keep the Doctor’s promise for him? Or is there another force at work trying to screw with the Time Lord? Nevertheless, Missy is now free of the Vault, though she doesn’t show any resistance towards having to go back. Is she actually reforming, or is this all a long-game Master plot?

Oh, and that cameo at the end with Alpha Centauri – a character from the classic series – being voiced by the original actress from over forty years ago was a nice touch.

I feel that whenever Mark Gatiss (co-creator of Sherlock, who also plays Mycroft on that show) writes an episode for Doctor Who, it’s very middle-of-the-road; nothing spectacular, but nothing particularly awful. Just a fine episode. The past two episodes he wrote for the Twelfth Doctor – “Robot of Sherwood” and “Sleep No More” – were mostly enjoyable, though the latter episode was definitely the weakest of Series 9. “Empress of Mars” is another fine Gatiss episode, though I feel that the morally conflicting themes and supporting character arc are what save it from just being another middle-of-the-road episode.

The Mummy: In theaters June 9.


Final verdict: 8/10.


NEXT WEEK: A centuries-old mystery is finally solved: What really happened to the missing Ninth Legion of Rome?

No comments:

Post a Comment